Parenthetical

YA reviews and book geekery

Parenthetical bookshelf

Jellicoe Road, by Melina Marchetta

January 31st, 2010 · 5 Comments

Jellicoe Road cover
I think Kristin recommended this one to me, in which case, props to you! Loved it. I finished it over a dinner shift at work and was totally sobbing in the library kitchen. But don’t worry; it’s not just a sad book — there’s plenty of funny, romantic, and hopeful in there as well.

I’m going to be vague about plot, because it’s nearly impossible to explain without giving things away. It’s a school story, a friendship story, and a family story, and that’s all I’ll say about that. (It also manages to hit several of my story kinks at once: Everything She Thought She Knew Was a Lie and epic connections between family members across time and chosen family. Plus, of course, Australia. Ooooh.)

I will say it took me a long time to get into it, longer than I would normally give a book, but I stuck with it because it came so highly recommended. There’s a long stretch where you will have not the foggiest clue what the hell is going on. “The Brigadier”? “The Hermit”? Doesn’t anyone have a bloody name in this book?

Power through that, though; it’s worth it. Even the stupid school territory battle, a convention I normally hate (I can never understand why kids in books take that sort of thing so seriously), comes clear in the end. It’s a beautifully put together gem of a book that would, I think, work packaged for adults as well. (If you are an adult who doesn’t normally read YA, let me know what you think.)

Question: Did you play some sort of Very Serious Game when you were in school, or did you know people who did? Something to do with territory wars, or hazing, or anything like that, where there were leaders and complicated rules that everyone took as gospel? And if so, can you explain to me why on earth you cared? Is it a British (and, I guess, Australian) thing?

Also reviewed at: Chicklish, The LibrariYAn, and YAnnabe.

Comment here

Tags: Reviews

5 responses so far ↓

  • 1 kristin cashore // Jan 31, 2010 at 4:36 pm

    *flails with happiness*

    I can’t remember if we’ve discussed Saving Francesca — have you read that one yet? If not, I recommend it (and could lend you it). It’s not as complicated, but it’s just as emotionally satisfying, IMO.

  • 2 Sam // Feb 1, 2010 at 8:27 pm

    …I started to write a whole thing about how you already lent me Saving Francesca, and it’s sitting on my desk half-finished because it hasn’t grabbed me. But then I realized that’s The Possibilities of Sainthood. Oops.

    So no, I haven’t read Saving Francesca! *Adds to Goodreads*

  • 3 Finnikin of the Rock, Melina Marchetta // Mar 22, 2010 at 12:43 pm

    [...] very complicated story by the author of one of my recent favorites, Jellicoe Road. She’s trying out fantasy this time: when Finnikin, son of the captain of the guard of [...]

  • 4 Saving Francesca, by Melina Marchetta (2003) // Jun 29, 2010 at 8:56 pm

    [...] didn’t love it like I loved Jellicoe Road, nor did it bug me like Finnikin of the Rock did. It’s a less complex book than either one, [...]

  • 5 Review: Chime, by Franny Billingsley // Sep 22, 2011 at 1:29 pm

    [...] is a Jellicoe Road. That’s become my shorthand for a wonderful but difficult book that I want to put down early, [...]

Leave a Comment